Implementation | November 17, 2026

Beyond Enrollmen⁠t⁠: Why Fam⁠i⁠ly Sa⁠t⁠⁠i⁠sfac⁠t⁠⁠i⁠on Ma⁠t⁠⁠t⁠ers ⁠i⁠n ESA Programs

By: C. Tracie Canestrari

C. Tracie Canestrari

Implementation

November 17, 2026

State administrators of ESA programs make a promise to families: that the program will help them find the education their children need. Enrollment shows that families signed up; their feedback shows whether the program delivered.

Family satisfaction data gives governors and legislators a direct way to see what is working and to identify issues, such as slow vendor approvals or confusing payment systems, before they erode public confidence. States that ask families for feedback and act on it are better positioned both to defend their programs and to improve them.

Are states measuring what matters most?

States often measure the success of education savings account (ESA) programs by enrollment and participation, but those numbers only tell part of the story. If the goal is to empower families to pursue the education that best meets their children’s needs, shouldn’t states also be asking whether the programs are actually working for them?

Families’ experiences navigating applications, accessing funds, and finding educational opportunities can reveal as much about a program’s success as the number of students enrolled.

Recent family satisfaction surveys from Missouri, West Virginia, South Carolina, and Tennessee offer encouraging results and practical insights into how states can continue to improve their programs.

What families are saying

Families pursue education savings accounts for different reasons. Some are looking for specialized services or tutoring, while others want a different school environment or greater flexibility in their child’s education. Although their priorities vary, they share an expectation that the program should make it easier to access the opportunities they’ve chosen.

Recent surveys suggest that many families are having positive experiences, although their feedback also highlights opportunities to make programs more accessible and easier to use.

South Carolina

South Carolina’s Education Oversight Committee surveyed families participating in the Education Scholarship Trust Fund for the 2025-26 school year, receiving 1,669 responses. Of those responding, 92% were classified as promoters, meaning they were highly likely to recommend the program.

Families valued the financial relief, flexibility, and access to educational opportunities, including specialized services that might otherwise have been out of reach. They also identified areas for improvement, particularly vendor approval timelines and invoice submissions, along with clearer guidance about eligible expenses.

Missouri

A recent Saint Louis University PRiME Center report examined three years of MOScholars family surveys and found that 99% of respondents were satisfied with the program overall, while 98% were satisfied with their child’s academic achievement.

Although families expressed strong appreciation for the opportunities the program provides, their written feedback also highlighted challenges with communication, particularly around award notifications, and navigating the ClassWallet payment platform. Some families also wanted greater flexibility in how scholarship funds could be used.

West Virginia

West Virginia’s 2025-26 Hope Scholarship Annual Report found that 96.42% of the 893 families responding were satisfied or very satisfied with the program. More than 95% reported satisfaction with communication, and approximately four out of five experienced no difficulty with the application process.

Families cited a range of reasons for participating, including religious-based education, concerns about public school curriculum, and greater flexibility. Their responses reinforce the importance of programs that accommodate different educational priorities and family needs.

Tennessee

A January 2026 evaluation by the Tennessee Comptroller’s Office found that overall satisfaction with the state’s ESA program remained around 94% to 95% across three annual surveys.

However, the evaluation also noted declining survey participation and recommended using consistent questions from year to year. These findings show why thoughtful survey design and reporting of response rates matter. Both help states understand whose experiences are reflected in the results.

Keep families at the center of success

The findings from Missouri, West Virginia, South Carolina, and Tennessee offer an encouraging picture of family satisfaction, but their greatest value may be what they reveal about improving ESA implementation. Families consistently appreciate the educational opportunities these programs provide, while also identifying challenges with communication, payment platforms, provider approvals, and access to funds. Tennessee’s experience also shows that how states collect feedback matters, particularly when it comes to reaching families and measuring progress over time.

Taken together, these findings demonstrate that family satisfaction surveys can be much more than a measure of whether parents are happy with a program. They can help administrators understand what’s working, identify barriers that might otherwise go unnoticed, and make informed decisions about where improvements are needed.

As more states launch and expand ESA programs, they have an opportunity to build this feedback into implementation from the start rather than waiting for problems to emerge. States can keep listening to and adapting to families’ needs by surveying them regularly, publishing the results, and using the findings to improve program operations.

After all, the goal isn’t simply to enroll more students or distribute more funding; it’s to empower families to pursue the educational opportunities that work best for their children. The families who use these programs every day should have a meaningful voice in determining how well states are accomplishing that goal.